Reservation
+1 845-595-1966
Visit Us
92 Windermere Ave, Greenwood Lake, NY 10925, United States
Hello dear
Welcome To 4 Brothers Pizzeria and Restaurant
At 4 Brothers Pizzeria and Restaurant, a cozy culinary haven in Greenwood Lake, NY, the spirit of family and tradition shines through every dish. Established with a passion for authentic Italian cuisine, this beloved eatery specializes in New York-style thin crust pizza, skillfully prepared using fresh ingredients. Guests rave about the warm, inviting atmosphere and attentive service, making it the perfect spot for family dinners or casual outings. Signature offerings like Chicken Soltimboca and delightful desserts like Cannoli highlight the menu's diversity. Whether dining indoors, on the porch, or curbside, 4 Brothers promises delectable meals that leave patrons coming back for more.
About
4 Brothers Pizzeria and Restaurant
Welcome to 4 Brothers Pizzeria and Restaurant, a beloved culinary gem nestled in the heart of Greenwood Lake, NY. Located at 92 Windermere Ave, this establishment brings a slice of New York's vibrant pizza culture to the community, offering an inviting atmosphere and a menu bursting with flavor.
At 4 Brothers, pizza isn’t just food—it’s an experience. With a signature thin crust, each pie is crafted to achieve that perfect crispy texture that every pizza lover craves. The passionate team behind the counter takes pride in every slice, ensuring that freshness and quality shine through. As many satisfied customers have noted, the fried calamari also deserves a mention—it’s crispy and flavorful, perfect as a starter.
- Family Dinner Specials: Catering to families, they offer fantastic deals—like their Family Dinner Special, which includes one pizza, two heroes, a large antipasto, and a 2-liter soda for just $54.99.
- Pizza and Wings: For those who love a classic pairing, their Pizza and Wings Special includes a large cheese pizza and a dozen wings, all for $32.99.
- Variety in Heroes and Subs: The menu boasts an array of sandwich options, like the Italian Combo Sub and Ham and Cheese Sub, running between $11.99 and $12.99, making it easy for everyone to find something they love.
- Chicken Dishes: Don't miss their delectable chicken offerings, such as Chicken Soltimboca and Chicken Parmigiana, each priced around $22.99.
The ambiance at 4 Brothers is noteworthy as well. Diners can choose to eat indoors, on the porch, or even by their cars, an option that has been especially appreciated during these times. Customers have praised the friendly and attentive staff, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. Reviews highlight the restaurant’s casual vibe and the well-rounded menu, making it perfect for a family outing or a casual night out.
While some have voiced concerns about extra charges, the overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive. Many visitors appreciate how the restaurant aims to keep safety a priority while maintaining top-notch service. Whether it’s a big slice enjoyed with family or a casual meal with friends, 4 Brothers Pizzeria and Restaurant promises a delicious experience.
Come and indulge your taste buds at 4 Brothers Pizzeria and Restaurant, where deliciousness and great deals come together to create food memories that you’ll cherish long after your visit.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Every staff member was polite and friendly. Food received fresh and quick. Family dinner for our family of 5. Some leftovers. Ate at 5pm, the restaurant was not too busy, radio a little loud for my taste, but could still have conversations easily. (maybe not so much if you had hearing aids) ”
“ Pizza had a nice crisp thin crust and the fried calamari was tasty. Service was also excellent ”
“ Nice owner and keeping safely first. You have an option to eat inside or by the porch or by your car. Pizza is thin crust and crispy very NY city style . Yummy and delicious. ”
“ I really like to eat in this place. The pizza is amazing. The dough is not too thin or thick. The sitting area outside is really nice. One objection I have is that I ordered a medium-sized pizza, which was 13.99. I asked for extra cheese, and I was charged 10.00 for the extra cheese. I was better off asking for a large pie. 10.00 for extra cheese is definitely way too much to charge. I believe 3.00 for extra cheese would have been fair. ”
“ This was exactly what I wanted tonight. Not fancy, laid back,good price, good pizza! You can get a big slice of pizza or a whole pie. They have other food options too. ”
“ Best pizza in Greenwood Lake hands down!!! We ordered for pick up a large pizza half pepperoni half hawaiian and it was delicious!!!! Mozz sticks were really good too I would just like them a little crispier. I will 100% come back ”
“ First time here. Kept it simple with a slice of cheese pizza and it was delicious. Dining outside on a 65 degree weather day made it just perfect! ”
“ If you’re not coming here for their Crazy Chicken slice, you’re wasting your time. Not to say their other pizza is “bad” but the Crazy Chicken pizza is the staple of their business. Highly recommended. Whenever I’m in the area this is my “go to” pizza spot. ”